Bookmark and Share
Printer Friendly

Biden in Israel: Day 3

David Streeter — March 10, 2010 – 5:20 pm | Foreign Policy | GOP Hypocrisies | Israel Comments (4) Add a comment

Yesterday after we posted “Biden in Israel: Day 2”, Vice President Joe Biden released a statement of disapproval regarding Israel’s decision to construct apartments in East Jerusalem. The reaction from the right-wing has been to trash Biden’s pro-Israel bona fides and to concoct conspiracy theories that question the strong support for Israel’s security that has been shown by President Barack Obama and his administration.

In total contrast, Israeli Interior Minister Eli Yishai, who was asked by Prime Minister Netanyahu not to allow any “surprises” during Biden’s visit, has apologized to Biden and dubbed the ill-timed announcement “unpleasant” and “regrettable.” Moreover, Defense Minister Ehud Barak labeled the announcement as “damaging” while one of his subordinates in the Defense Ministry echoed Biden’s words about the action being detrimental to the newly re-started peace talks. Additionally, one right-wing Knesset member accused Netanyahu and his cabinet of not being truthful with Biden.

The situation that unfolded last night represents a highly nuanced and complex issue that has rattled the current Israeli government. American and Israeli policies on this issue have differed for over forty years; if anyone thinks that Biden’s statement was unprecedented, one only needs to look at the behavior of Republican President George H.W. Bush in 1991 and the statements by Republican Presidents George W. Bush and Ronald Reagan regarding settlements.  

Settlements aside, it does appear that Biden made progress towards coaxing the Palestinians towards discontinuing their anti-Israel incitement. According to both Ha’Aretz and The Jerusalem Post, the Palestinian Authority (PA) cancelled a memorial ceremony for a terrorist who murdered Israelis along the Haifa-Tel Aviv Highway in 1978. The PA’s announcement followed today’s meetings between Biden and Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas and Palestinian Prime Minister Salam Fayaad.

Tomorrow, Biden will speak at Tel Aviv University in a speech that will be televised in the United States at 4:30am Eastern/1:30am Pacific.

Comments

Joshua | March 11, 2010 – 1:06 am

So, does that mean you support the division of Jerusalem as well?

Hillel Markowitz | March 11, 2010 – 6:00 pm

Has Biden apologized to Israel for condeming building within its capital city? It would be like having someone object to the United States building in Georgetown or stating that San Francisco is a Mexican city.

Shmuel | March 11, 2010 – 11:21 pm

Your e-mail said, “While it’s important to note that the Interior Minister apologized to the Vice President, it’s also important to place this issue in historical context.”

The historical context is this: East Jerusalem was ethnically cleansed of Jews in ‘48, together with everywhere else east of the Green Line. Having done that, the Palestinian Arabs and the Jordanian army proceeded to desecrate and/or destroy every synagogue, yeshiva, cemetery, and Jewish holy place to which they had access.

Israel has done a miserable job of getting these facts, and the supporting documentation and photographs, in front of the media. Joe Biden’s statement was a perfect opportunity to do so. Instead, Israel apologized.

There is nothing to be gained by being coy and evasive: Through their actions between 1948 and 1967, when they controlled East Jerusalem, the Palestinians forfeited any right to have that control returned to them.

By the way, you say that “the Palestinian Authority (PA) cancelled a memorial ceremony for a terrorist who murdered Israelis along the Haifa-Tel Aviv Highway in 1978.” My understanding—correct me if I’m wrong—is that they are still going to name the traffic circle after her.

Shmuel | March 17, 2010 – 5:39 am

East Jerusalem was ethnically cleansed of Jews in ‘48, together with everywhere else east of the Green Line. Having done that, the Palestinian Arabs and the Jordanian army proceeded to desecrate and/or destroy every synagogue, yeshiva, cemetery, and Jewish holy place to which they had access. No Palestinian spokesperson has yet come forward to say, “Hey, our bad. But of course we would never, ever do anything like that again.”

Israel has done a miserable job of getting these facts, and the supporting documentation and photographs, in front of the media. Joe Biden’s statement was a perfect opportunity to do so. Instead, Israel apologized.

There is nothing to be gained by being coy and evasive: Through their actions between 1948 and 1967, when they controlled East Jerusalem, the Palestinians forfeited any right to have that control returned to them.

Add a Comment
Note: This form does not support AOL's browser. If you are currently using AOL's browser, please use a major browser, such as Firefox, Safari, Chrome, or Internet Explorer.